So some of my girlfriends and I went to see the new movie Eat, Pray, Love last week.
And I enjoyed it.
I wasn't blown away by it - but I enjoyed it.
I suppose I should start off by admitting right up front that I did not read the book. I have not been in a book club for over 10 years and, without that sort of "you have to be able to discuss this book with a bunch of other women" cattle prod against my backside, the number of books I read at all has dropped sharply.
And I suppose I should also take a moment to clarify my feelings about book clubs in general.
I don't so much like them.
I don't have a problem with them for other people - I think they are a great boon to the publishing industry. Come to think of it - if I ever have a book published, book clubs will very quickly become one of my Very Favorite Things Ever.
But right now, for me personally - not so much.
Perhaps this is because the books chosen by book clubs are almost always either depressing, or designed to teach me something, or both. And, already by the age of 47, I have lived a life pretty close to gritty reality. So I'm not too interested in being depressed or enlightened. Think of me as someone who is very happy in my own personal church and not interested in your particular watchtower type pamphlet.
What I love about book clubs is getting together with a bunch of my friends over some drinks and some snacks for a good chin wag. Just without having to go to the trouble of reading a book first. And particularly without having to intelligently address whatever the main point of the book was.
I hated doing book reports in school. In fact, it was one of the things I thought was really cool about graduating and joining the ranks of the non-student - no more book reports.
So one of my goals for this fall is to start - amongst my circle of friends - a "Book Free Book Club". The point being to get together regularly once a month at each other's homes and eat and drink and not discuss a book. We may bring books and recommend them, we may talk about a book we particularly loved from our past or present, we may discuss films - good and bad - we may talk about our children and our husbands and the state of the world.
But we will not read a book.
But I digress.
Eat Pray Love.
I went to the movie for two reasons: 1) I love any excuse to get together with friends (see above) and 2) I actually saw Julia Roberts and Elizabeth Gilbert on Oprah plugging the movie and it looked really great and funny and inspiring.
And it sort of was.
Except I guess I have been doing my own brand of soul searching for the past 5 years - particularly while dealing with several friends with breast cancer, one of whom didn't make it - and I didn't see a very meaningful journey and/or transformation when I watched the movie.
It was a beautiful movie and I found Julia Roberts engaging as always. But, from the beginning when she bailed on her marriage, I found it difficult to find the Elizabeth character sympathetic and engaged on a meaningful quest for fulfillment - which is, I believe, how the character is being marketed. Rather, she came off as shallow and narcissistic. And, by the end, she didn't seem very transformed - just with a different guy.
Please don't take this as a judgement of Elizabeth Gilbert herself - this was just the feeling I got from the movie. And, to be fair, the book probably does a better job at making her journey clearer. Movies are great for storytelling but not always so great for internal philosophical narrative.
So, since Thursday's posts are supposed to be inspiring, and I realize that, so far, this post has been anything but, I would like to mention a few films that I did find to be truly inspiring as well as entertaining.
1) Chocolat --- one of my all time favorites and my inspiration to become a chocolatier.
2) Last Holiday --- the movie that helped me most when my cousin was dying of cancer. If I ever have to face a terminal illness, I'll be using this film as a template.
3) Julie and Julia ---- this is the movie that inspired me to blog and to pick a dream to stick to for once. And I loved the message that we should all find someone like Julia Child to inspire us to be bigger, less judgemental people.
Bonus - all three films have the most wonderful food - better than Eat Pray Love.
Drawback - after watching them, you'll probably go out and binge on something full of butter or chocolate and gain 10 pounds.
Go ahead and go see Eat Pray Love - I did enjoy it.
But then rent one of those films and invite your friends over to watch it with you.
Recent Comments