Review: OK - straight out of the gate - this might be my new favorite apple pie recipe!
Found on page 302 of the 1950 Betty Crocker Picture Cookbook, this apple pie is super easy and amazingly delicious!
It uses the basic Betty vintage crust, tart apples, cinnamon sugar, butter, and grated cheese.
Reproduced here for educational purposes and to encourage people to go buy a copy of the original book.
If you need the master recipe for the crust click here and the recipe referred to in this one click here.
Now for my notes on the recipe:
1) I'm ignoring that little verse about a kiss and a squeeze - it was 1950.
2) I have no idea what "sharp yellow American cheese" was - we have so many cheeses now that the cheese referred to here maybe no longer exists or is probably called something more specific. I decided to opt for a medium cheddar and it came out great. I think I'm going to keep making this recipe and experiment with other semi-hard cheeses.
3) It says nothing about the temperature of the butter - I used room temp butter so that it would not poke through the crust - it worked fine and baked up well but would have been a real mess to work with if I didn't have some great tricks for handling wet dough - see below for these.
4) Pay close attention to the fact that the cheese goes in the TOP CRUST ONLY.
5) If you have taken the time to read through the methods for rolling out dough (page 300) you will know that Betty Crocker recommends using a pastry set - this consists of a large cloth on which to roll out the dough and a "pastry sock" which covers the rolling pin. When you make a crust like the cheese crust these extra tools are really important! They help you handle the dough without adding a lot of extra flour that would make the crust tough.
I have been using a pastry cloth for years and I SWEAR by it. I also use plastic wrap as you will see in my "tips" section below. Pastry cloths and pastry socks are readily available on the internet and very inexpensive.
5) When I "rolled it up like a jelly roll" and then folded it in on itself it was pretty shaggy looking but it still worked.
6) It says to serve warm - I ate a piece that was still warm and it was heavenly - and the cheese had a slight chewiness to it that was surprisingly good. I ate another piece later that was cold and, while still very tasty, it was definitely better when it was warm.
Things I did differently:
1) I used my own personal crust recipe that is half butter and half shortening (the Betty recipe is 100% shortening) Click here for my piecrust recipe.
2) I sprayed the top crust lightly with water and then sprinkled course "raw" sugar over it. I always finish my fruit pies this way - Betty offers it as an option on page 307 in the "beauty touches for pies" section.
3) I baked it at a lower temperature - I always bake my apple pies at 350 (low in the oven to help the bottom crust brown better). All ovens are different and, over the years, I've discovered that if I bake a pie at the 425 degrees in the recipe I will have a burnt top crust by the time the filling starts to bubble up. I probably should stick a thermometer in there and see what's going on with my oven.
Because I baked it at a lower temp I did leave it in about 20 minutes longer than it says in the recipe - but I checked it every 10 minutes once I passed the 35 minute mark.
So one of my biggest tips about handling piecrusts is the use of plastic wrap (or "cling film" for you international readers). I use it at various stages of the pastry making process (you can do everything shown here with just two pieces of wrap - one for the top and one for the bottom) - here are my tips and tricks and a couple pics of this specific pie:
I not only use plastic wrap to gather the dough into a ball, I also start rolling it out into a disk while it is still in the plastic wrap
Then, still in the plastic wrap, I flip the dough over and roll some more so it's nice and smooth with no cracks
After I unwrap the dough from the plastic wrap I lay it on the lightly floured pastry cloth and cover the top with the same piece of plastic wrap - then I don't have to use a pastry sock - lift the plastic occasionally and re-position so that the dough will continue to stretch. Another advantage of the plastic is that it keeps the dough from cracking so much at the edges.
If you roll the dough with plastic wrap on top it will stick enough to help you get the crust safely into the pan and even adjust it - remove plastic before filling the pie!
Add the apples in layers of thin slices and sprinkle with cinnamon sugar and dot with butter between each layer - a layer uses about 1 1/2 medium sized apples
Here is what the cheese crust looked like when I rolled it up- notice how shaggy the edges are.
Now the jellyroll has been folded inward twice - it's VERY messy but we will fix it.
I used the plastic wrap again to force the cheesy buttered crust back into a ball and eventually a nice disk - this is how we fix all those cracks and also keep the soft butter from making a mess everywhere
Again I've rolled the crust out using a floured pastry cloth underneath and plastic wrap over the top
I've used plastic wrap to help transfer the crust and adjust it on the top of the filled pan
Gathering the top and bottom crust together and folding it over to seal the pie can be a messy business - again - plastic wrap can help with this
This is the last time I will use the plastic - to help make the fluted edge of the pie - this dough is too messy to put my fingers directly in contact with the crust - it just sticks to them and makes a giant mess.
I keep a generic spray bottle (available at dollar stores) filled with water so that wetting down the top crust is super easy.
After I've sprayed the top of the pie with water I sprinkle brown "raw" sugar over the top for extra texture and crunch!
My last tip - whenever I make a pie that is going to bubble up and release a lot of juice while baking I put a pizza pan underneath it to catch everything. I learned this the hard way after a 'pie-juice-sugar-fire"
Recent Comments